Straight From NY Pizza South

New York Style Pizza by the Slice

Classic New York style slices sold individually, making it easy to get a quick and affordable meal.

• Good value for a single slice, according to reviewers
• Popular options include combination and Hawaiian slices
• Ask for a freshly made slice if you want the best quality

Whole New York Style Pies

Full-size pizzas with hand-tossed dough, suited to family dinners and shared meals.

• Monday night large pizza pricing noted by reviewers as a strong value
• Dough is hand-tossed, a detail customers notice while waiting
• Pineapple-only pizza is available for those who want it

Specialty Pies

Signature and specialty pizzas that go beyond the basics, including vegetarian options.

• Pesto vegetarian pie is recommended by one reviewer as a favorite
• Hawaiian and pineapple pizzas are popular with reviewers
• Pepperoni is a classic choice on the menu

Delivery and Takeout

Pizza can be ordered for pickup or delivered through DoorDash, according to customer reports.

• Reviewers report DoorDash delivery from this location
• Takeout is a good option for shared family meals at home
• Dine-in is available for a relaxed sit-down meal

“Some of the best pizza in the region, definitely the best New York style. A little pricey, does offer pizza by the slice, good value for the money. Monday night large pizza is $18, best value in town on a Monday evening. Restrooms are kept clean and nice. Staff is very friendly, you don’t often see pizza dough made the old-fashioned way. When I was waiting for my pizza this evening, I saw them tossing the pizza dough and I asked if they were OK if I took pictures. One each time dough was “tossed”. TV sports usually on but no sound unless a big game? No background music, there’s something maybe that could be worked on. But generally, it is quiet and a pleasant place to sit alone and eat or to have a family night or even a date night. Just feels like home. Some of the interior fixtures show signs of wear just from age, well taken care of and clean but could use updating. I highly recommend this location, an excellent place to take a family on Monday evening for family pizza night. Also, DoorDash now delivers from here. Pineapple only pizza was requested by my daughter so don’t hold it against the host!”

“Loved this place, it was my first time there. I had a slice of combination and my husband had a slice of Hawaiian. Even the grease ran off the Pizza like They say it happens in New York. The pizza slices were in a Glass cabinet out front. He heated it up and it tasted like it just came out of the Stone brick oven. Our server was great. We will be back. We really enjoyed ourselves.”

“When it comes to Pizza by the slice and New York style pizza, this is one of the better pizza places in Salem. Here's a tip though. Make sure you get there early as I've found that sometimes they heaters don't keep the pizza very fresh and if you go at the end of the day unless you ask them to make it fresh, you're going to get lower quality than what you will if it's fresh. Try going during the day and getting the pesto vegetarian.. it's definitely my favorite”

“Haven't been here in a long while but unfortunately won't be going again. Sure, prices for a couple slices is low, but the quality of the flavorless pizza isn't there at all. The pepperoni had no flavor, the sauce needed seasoning. And 'warming' up the old pizza just isn't appealing, along with all of the food being open for flies to land on.”

The Grand Hotel in Salem

⭐ 4.5 (1405) · 1.8 miles

201 Liberty Street Southeast, Salem

Love Love Teriyaki

⭐ 4.3 (475) · 1.7 miles

4555 Liberty Road South #250, Salem

Word Of Mouth Neighborhood Bistro

⭐ 4.7 (2884) · 2.0 miles

140 17th Street Northeast, Salem

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

⭐ 4.3 (5732) · 3.8 miles

1302 Lancaster Drive Northeast, Salem

Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews

⭐ 3.9 (4104) · 3.5 miles

831 Lancaster Drive Northeast, Salem

Subway

⭐ 3.9 (155) · < 0.1 miles

2914 Commercial Street Southeast, Salem